As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Reading order

Whatever After Books in Order

This page lists the complete Whatever After reading order by Sarah Mlynowski, with book numbers, publication years, and a publication-order view for readers who want to start at the beginning.

Updated 2026-06-22 / 17 books / 2012-2025

Whatever After Reading Order

01 Fairest of All 2012 Buy
02 If the Shoe Fits 2012 Buy
03 Sink or Swim 2013 Buy
04 Dream On 2013 Buy
05 Bad Hair Day 2014 Buy
06 Cold As Ice 2014 Buy
07 Beauty Queen 2015 Buy
08 Once Upon a Frog 2015 Buy
09 Genie in a Bottle 2016 Buy
10 Sugar and Spice 2016 Buy
11 Two Peas in a Pod 2018 Buy
12 Seeing Red 2018 Buy
13 Spill the Beans 2019 Buy
14 Good as Gold 2021 Buy
15 Just Dance 2022 Buy
16 Liar, Liar 2024 Buy
17 Mirror Mirror 2025 Buy

Whatever After Books by Publication Order

2012 Fairest of All #1
2012 If the Shoe Fits #2
2013 Sink or Swim #3
2013 Dream On #4
2014 Bad Hair Day #5
2014 Cold As Ice #6
2015 Beauty Queen #7
2015 Once Upon a Frog #8
2016 Genie in a Bottle #9
2016 Sugar and Spice #10
2018 Two Peas in a Pod #11
2018 Seeing Red #12
2019 Spill the Beans #13
2021 Good as Gold #14
2022 Just Dance #15
2024 Liar, Liar #16
2025 Mirror Mirror #17

Questions readers ask

What is the correct Whatever After reading order?

The Whatever After reading order on this page follows the numbered series order where available, with publication years shown beside each book.

How many Whatever After books are there?

This catalog currently lists 17 Whatever After books published across 2012-2025.

Who writes the Whatever After books?

Whatever After is listed as a book series by Sarah Mlynowski.

Should I read Whatever After in publication order?

For most readers, publication order is the safest way to read Whatever After. If a separate series order is available, this page shows that order first and publication years beside each title.

More by Sarah Mlynowski

Sarah Mlynowski books in order and complete bibliography ->

Source note: Sequencebooks organizes author, book, and series records from its catalog data. Publication years and series order are shown when available.