As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Reading order

Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries Books in Order

This page lists the complete Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries reading order by Amy Lillard, with book numbers, publication years, and a publication-order view for readers who want to start at the beginning.

Updated 2026-06-22 / 27 books / 2015-2025

Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries Reading Order

01 Peace Like a River(By: Olivia Newport) 2015 Buy
02 Blessing in Disguise(By: Nancy Mehl) 2015 Buy
03 Where Hope Dwells(By: Elizabeth Ludwig) 2015 Buy
04 The Buggy Before the Horse(By: Tricia Goyer) 2015 Buy
05 A Season of Secrets(By: Elizabeth Adams) 2015 Buy
06 O Little Town of Sugarcreek(By: Amy Lee Lillard) 2015 Buy
07 Off the Beaten Path(By: Annalisa Daughety) 2015 Buy
08 Simply Vanished(By: Nancy Mehl) 2016 Buy
09 Stranger Things Have Happened 2016 Buy
10 No Time for Trouble(By: Olivia Newport) 2016 Buy
11 A Stitch in Time(By: Elizabeth Ludwig) 2016 Buy
12 Shoo, FLY, Shoo 2016 Buy
13 Home Sweet Sugarcreek(By: Elizabeth Ludwig) 2016 Buy
14 When There's a Will(By: Elizabeth Adams) 2016 Buy
15 In a Jam(By: Elizabeth Adams) 2016 Buy
16 All Abuzz at the Honey Bee(By: Nancy Mehl) 2016 Buy
17 Mason Jar Mayhem(By: Cara C. Putman) 2016 Buy
18 Earthly Treasures(By: Annalisa Daughety) 2016 Buy
19 A Tempting Taste Of Mystery(By: Elizabeth Ludwig) 2017 Buy
20 Digging Up Doubts(By: Olivia Newport) 2017 Buy
21 A Play On Words(By: Emily Thomas) 2017 Buy
22 In the Fullness of Time(By: Elizabeth Adams) 2017 Buy
23 Horse Sense and Sensibility(By: Nancy Mehl) 2017 Buy
24 Secrets Plain and Simple(By: Elizabeth Ludwig) 2018 Buy
25 When Angels Whisper(By: Nancy Mehl) 2022 Buy
26 Hark! The Herald Angel Falls(By: Tricia Goyer) 2024 Buy
27 O Little Town of Sugarcreek 2025 Buy

Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries Books by Publication Order

2015 Peace Like a River(By: Olivia Newport) #1
2015 Blessing in Disguise(By: Nancy Mehl) #2
2015 Where Hope Dwells(By: Elizabeth Ludwig) #3
2015 The Buggy Before the Horse(By: Tricia Goyer) #4
2015 A Season of Secrets(By: Elizabeth Adams) #5
2015 O Little Town of Sugarcreek(By: Amy Lee Lillard) #6
2015 Off the Beaten Path(By: Annalisa Daughety) #7
2016 Simply Vanished(By: Nancy Mehl) #8
2016 Stranger Things Have Happened #9
2016 No Time for Trouble(By: Olivia Newport) #10
2016 A Stitch in Time(By: Elizabeth Ludwig) #11
2016 Shoo, FLY, Shoo #12
2016 Home Sweet Sugarcreek(By: Elizabeth Ludwig) #13
2016 When There's a Will(By: Elizabeth Adams) #14
2016 In a Jam(By: Elizabeth Adams) #15
2016 All Abuzz at the Honey Bee(By: Nancy Mehl) #16
2016 Mason Jar Mayhem(By: Cara C. Putman) #17
2016 Earthly Treasures(By: Annalisa Daughety) #18
2017 A Tempting Taste Of Mystery(By: Elizabeth Ludwig) #19
2017 Digging Up Doubts(By: Olivia Newport) #20
2017 A Play On Words(By: Emily Thomas) #21
2017 In the Fullness of Time(By: Elizabeth Adams) #22
2017 Horse Sense and Sensibility(By: Nancy Mehl) #23
2018 Secrets Plain and Simple(By: Elizabeth Ludwig) #24
2022 When Angels Whisper(By: Nancy Mehl) #25
2024 Hark! The Herald Angel Falls(By: Tricia Goyer) #26
2025 O Little Town of Sugarcreek #27

Questions readers ask

What is the correct Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries reading order?

The Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries reading order on this page follows the numbered series order where available, with publication years shown beside each book.

How many Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries books are there?

This catalog currently lists 27 Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries books published across 2015-2025.

Who writes the Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries books?

Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries is listed as a book series by Amy Lillard.

Should I read Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries in publication order?

For most readers, publication order is the safest way to read Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries. If a separate series order is available, this page shows that order first and publication years beside each title.

More by Amy Lillard

Amy Lillard books in order and complete bibliography ->

Source note: Sequencebooks organizes author, book, and series records from its catalog data. Publication years and series order are shown when available.